Queer Apologists
When the amendment allowing Gay Marriage in California first passed, I waited for the collective sigh of relief that was sure to come from the LGBTQ community. It mostly did come, but not without a few hiccups.
It took exactly five minutes for posts to start appearing on my Facebook wall saying things like, “Pardon me while I don’t dance in the streets that we can finally marry in California. It’s racist to demand marriage rights for Gays as long as People of Color are still being discriminated against!”, and “Gay marriage doesn’t matter while girls are still being circumsized against their will in parts of Africa!”
Or my personal favorite, “I will not be getting Gay-Married because Gay people need to focus on things that REALLY matter instead of seeking heteronormative institutions!”
I was saddened but not surprised to see that people in the Queer community didn’t wholly embrace the small victory that California had handed down. After all, we Queers don’t all think alike yanno. My sadness mainly centered around the negative statements being hurled at friends of mine who were Queer and had decided to get married by Queer friends of mine who had not decided to get married for some of the reasons listed above.
Such judgment. Such aggressive posturing.
Fast forward to this morning. I woke up with an extra pep in my step because I knew that President Obama was going to sign into law the bill allowing my Gay and Lesbian Brothers and Sisters to openly serve in the Military. Without hiding who they were, without shame.
The end to a 17-year-long journey toward equality in the Military.
I was and am so very proud of President Obama for having the gumption to take a stand for equal rights and for pushing through all of the adversity to get this bill passed. What an amazing achievement for our President and our country.
Fast forward just a few hours more. I log into my Facebook account and see various friends sharing the news story about President Obama signing this bill into law. There are lots of “likes” and comments and thankful rejoicing.
This time, however, it took exactly one hour for someone from my own Queer community to start sqwuaking about how GLBTQ soldiers being allowed to openly serve wasnt necessarily something to celebrate, because “Queer soldiers are still agents of genocide.”
And here we go again with the olympics of how GLBTQ people can’t be happy when we gain just a sliver of equality or a crumb of equal rights because “someone else either has it worse than we do” or because we really are just “buying into the system by demanding equal rights in the first place”.
I am so SICK of Gay people subjugating themselves and their own rights at the feet of the oppression olympics beast. It seems that within our own community, it has become passe to celebrate any achievement of equality, lest we step on the oppression of another, even if the person’s oppression on which we step overlaps heavily and cosmically with our own as Gay people.
Because last I checked, Queer people are People of Color, differently-abled, differently classed, educationally disadvataged, addicted, discriminated against, beaten, raped, robbed, marginalized, and subjected to all of the -isms that most of the world encounters. Because Gay and Lesbian people are not all White, upper middle class, able, and aware. Because those Queer folks of color want to get Gay Married and serve openly as well. Because those Queers who are poor put just as much stock into getting married and serving openly as they do trying to get ahead.
Because being able to marry your partner and serve openly doesn’t make us racist or insensitive to the oppression of others. It makes us a group of people who are finally seeing a pinprick of light in a very dark chasm of oppression after a very, very long time.
My point is this: In the Queer world, we often brainwash each other into giving up our joy over things like this. We often waggle virtual fingers at each other about how “we’re not doing it right” by writing manifestos about how Gay folks who want to get Gay married are hurting their fellow Queers and buying into racism. We refuse to dance when our Lesbian cousin who has been serving in the Navy under super-oppressive conditions can finally exhale all of that silence and just be.
We don’t raise our hands together in victory.
Instead, we apologize to the world and to each other for demanding better than we have been given and we sabotage each other’s happiness and, by default, ruin our cohesiveness as a Queer community by gobbling up those heaping spoonfuls of shame with both hands.
Because it IS shame, ladies and gentlemen, when we take a step forward in our collective journey toward freedom and can’t appreciate where we are because we are either too busy pontificating about how we don’t deserve to take that step, or we’re looking across the way, trying to figure out how to make someone else’s path easier.
And if that isn’t buying into what the Patriarchy expects of us? I don’t know what is.
Don’t get me wrong, I think that Queer folks do have a huge responsibility to look at other forms of oppression and try to combat them since all oppression is pretty well linked. I sometimes feel, though, that Queer folks have deemed themselves to be the “United States” of the world and come to everyone’s rescue, no matter the cost to our own community.
I’m still doing some thinking around this and why it pisses me off so deeply. Trying to check my White Privilege while doing this thinking is hard but necessary.
In the meantime, I rejoice over the repeal of DADT and I don’t give a damn which of my Queer friends thinks I’m a bad, bad Queer for doing it.